Monday, October 22, 2007
For those who recall the word illegal to undocumented Immigrants and criminalize them just because the crossed border. I am wonder which name they should be using on this case.
Sex offender was hired as informant when he didn't register as a sex offender,( it's a felonny)not paying taxes for his earning money since 1983 (Federal Offense), drove his car without a driver license(State Violation), without insurance(State Violation).
Why in the world this man was unnoticed by Local, State, Federal police Authorities? How many more are there? Hartline matter-of-factly admitted to a record that includes three DWIs, a domestic violence conviction involving an ex-wife and a sexual assault conviction involving a woman he was seeing while working as an informant
Agencies hired sex offender as informant
"Doc" slipped in and out of Warroad, buying drugs and guns while living outside the law himself.
DULUTH - Craig Allen Hartline is a convicted sex offender, but when he moved to Minnesota last year he didn't register, which is a felony. He earned $14,000 while working here, but didn't file a tax return and admits he hasn't filed one since 1983.
He also drove his van back and forth across the state, without a license.
How did Hartline go unnoticed by state law enforcement authorities?
They were paying him.
Officials said Friday they were surprised and somewhat embarrassed to learn they planted an unregistered sex offender in Warroad last year when they hired the 55-year-old Hartline, called him "Doc" and set him up to buy drugs and guns in the back of a secondhand store.
Agents fitted "Doc's Superthrift Store" in the town's old Hardware Hank building with hidden microphones and cameras. The purchases he made there for the Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension (BCA) and local police led to charges against 53 people, 30 of whom have pleaded guilty so far.
Police and prosecutors were happy with Doc's work, but admit being distressed to learn in preparation for trials that he had been convicted of a sex offense in Massachusetts in 1993, was registered in that state as a sex offender and hadn't registered in Minnesota as required when the BCA invited him to work here.
He told agency officials he had pleaded no contest to a trumped-up charge and didn't think it was something he had to disclose, and it hadn't turned up during an earlier background check.
"We hit some bumps in the road with this operation," Roseau County Attorney Lisa Hanson acknowledged. "But for the most part it went smoothly, and the results were good."
While attorneys who represent some of the defendants acknowledge that sometimes it takes a crook to catch a crook, they say it's unfair for Doc to get off for his crimes while their clients battle charges they wouldn't face if he hadn't offered them the opportunity.
"The BCA has an entire program to compel [sex-offender] registration, and then they give this guy a pass and let him handle weapons and not pay taxes," said Fred Friedman of Duluth, chief public defender for northeastern Minnesota. "Someone ought to be ashamed of themselves."
'We don't turn a blind eye'
Whether things would have been done differently if officials had known about Doc's background is uncertain.
"Had we known his whole background, it would have been factored in to our decision on whether to use him," said Dave Bjerga, the BCA's assistant superintendent. "But I don't know what the decision would have been."
A representative for the federal Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco and Firearms (ATF), which had used Hartline in a similar operation in North Dakota just before the Warroad sting, said she wouldn't be able to comment on whether he's still working for ATF.
"It would be nice if we were able to say all our informants have clean backgrounds, but unfortunately that's probably never going to be the case," said Sherry Duval, public information officer for the ATF's office in St. Paul. "But we don't turn a blind eye. If we know they're committing criminal activity while we're using them, they're done."
A year ago, Doc suddenly left Warroad, a Canadian border town of 1,700, after only four months there and 63 law-enforcement officers suddenly swarmed in to make arrests. Local folks said it didn't surprise them to learn that Doc was a snitch.
"He left just as suddenly as he came," Jackie Bengtson, owner of the Main Street Bar & Grill, said at the time. "We didn't feel creeped out by him, but he was a shady character."
Attorney Bruce Biggins of International Falls, who helped win an acquittal in July for Lonnie Gene Davis -- the only defendant so far to go to trial -- said he and co-counsel James Austad of Grand Rapids, Minn., argued to the jury that Hartline had entrapped their client by complaining frequently of back pain and begging Davis, who worked for him in the store, to sell him some of his prescription pain pills.
That trial also provided a window into the background of Hartline, who had previously been identified in court documents only as "BCA X-1886." He testified that in the 24 years since leaving the military, he had informed for more than 10 agencies in a dozen states, not because he had gotten in trouble himself but rather because "this is the career I've chosen."
He estimated that he had made more than 7,500 controlled buys of narcotics and guns, leading to 3,000 felony arrests. In early 2006, he was finishing up an undercover storefront operation run by the ATF in Dunseith, N.D., when BCA agents recruited him to work in Warroad.
His contract with the BCA promised $2,000 a month, plus $50 to $100 for each controlled "buy." Hartline said, and authorities confirmed, that he grossed more than $14,000 for his Warroad work.
"It's somewhat gratifying," he testified. "I make an impact on the communities that I go to. ... I consider myself a professional at what I do, and I don't like to be labeled as a snitch."
Under cross-examination, Hartline matter-of-factly admitted to a record that includes three DWIs, a domestic violence conviction involving an ex-wife and a sexual assault conviction involving a woman he was seeing while working as an informant.
He admitted that he didn't pay taxes on what he made from the BCA, and in fact had not filed a tax return since 1983. He also admitted that when he drove to meet BCA agents who were recruiting him, he didn't even have a driver's license.
Prosecutor Hanson said Friday that "no charges are pending" in Roseau County against Hartline for failing to register as a sex offender, though she has not ruled out that possibility.
She said his status in Massachusetts didn't turn up in the BCA's first record check because that state didn't have all its records in a computerized database at that point.
As soon as the BCA learned he was a sex offender, agents made him register while he was working his next undercover job in the state, Hanson said.
Even after Doc's stint in Warroad, he left behind possible signs of a repeated history.
One of the defendants convicted of selling him drugs filed a notice of claim with the city and Roseau County. She alleged that, in September 2006, he slipped her a date-rape drug in a drink and sexually assaulted her.
Hanson said no criminal investigation was done because the woman never reported the allegations to police. Hanson also pointed out that the woman's notice of claim, typically the precursor to a lawsuit, was not filed until after she learned of Doc's sex-crime conviction